Mar 06, 2020

The No Bullshit Way to Bake Your Own Bread

Want to make no knead bread in a Dutch oven? It's not nearly as hard as it sounds. 

Simple sourdough! No knead bread in a Dutch oven

Gluten is my homeboy. I don't care what the fad-diets say (and apologies to those of you who are truly gluten-intolerant). Paleo-be-damned, I'm grateful our ancestors developed agriculture, so we could stop foraging and eat mostly bread (and also develop science, art, culture, etc.). 

Great bread is easy to make. This is a no-knead recipe! Meaning, you don't, um... knead it. Duh. It's based on the Jim Lahey no knead bread recipe.

Here's how I do it:    

1. Get a sourdough starter from a friend (or make your own, or order one online).

2. In a plastic bin with an airtight lid (I use this one), mix until just combined:


  • 11 ounces of all purpose flour
  • 8 ounces of sourdough starter
  • 10 ounces of room-temperature water
  • 1 tsp salt (more or less, to taste)

3. Cover tightly and let the dough sit at room temp for twelve-ish hours. Then put it in the fridge for a while (a few hours, overnight, several days, doesn't really matter).

4. When you're ready to bake, turn your oven to 450 degrees (convection on if you have it), and put an enameled cast-iron pot (dutch oven) inside, with the lid on. If you don't have one, try any heavy-bottomed cookware (something that will retain a lot of heat).

Forming the sourdough boule

5. While the pot is heating up (30-45 minutes), pour your dough onto a well-floured countertop. Love your dough. Be gentle with your dough. Don't pound, knead, or stretch it. With flour-y hands (or a bench scraper), quickly fold the dough over once,  rotate 90 degrees, and fold over again. Now (Gently! Lovingly! Sensually? No, just gently is fine) work the sides of the dough down underneath it, rotating as you go, until it becomes a boule. You should be gradually stretching the top of the boule down underneath until you have a nice, smooth, round hunk of dough.

6. Take out the dutch oven and put the boule in. Use plenty of flour (on your hands, and dusted all over the dough) to make this easier. Should you burn your hands on the extremely hot cast iron? No! You should avoid that. Once it's in, make four quick slashes in the dough using a very sharp knife (or razor blade, or katana sword). Cover and return to the oven.

Slashed boule in the pot

7. 30-or-so minutes later, check your bread. It should be mostly done springing up. Now you can remove the lid from the dutch oven, and rotate the pot for more even baking, and leave it in the oven another 30-ish minutes. Note the vague time indications; bread is done when it looks, smells, and sounds (and tastes) done. A timer is a crutch.

(Below: oven spring is done, this one is ready to bake uncovered)

Oven spring

8. Wait for the bread to look and sound done (knock on the bottom, it should sound delicious and hollow but not dried out). Better to over-bake than under-bake it (if you're unsure). I wait for some of the wispy parts to start turning almost black/charred. 

sourdough bread is done

9. Take it out and let cool on a cooling rack, fending off your hungry children/spouse with the katana sword, saying 'Back! Back savages! Can't you see it's resting!?' Defend your beloved loaf of bread.

Yum. Easy no knead sourdough

That's it. Slice it nice and thick, spraying crispy crust crumbs all over the place. If you manage not to eat it all in one sitting, store it out on a cutting board, sliced side down, or in a paper bag.

Ours never lasts more than 24 hours. 



1. Ask someone else - I'm not an expert baker.

2. If your dough is way too sticky/wet to work with when you take it out of the fridge, try a little less water (I use 9oz. instead of ten).

3. Dough is too dense? Make sure you're handling it gently during shaping. Once it's out of the fridge, you want to keep as much air in it as possible.

4. Not enough initial spring? Make sure your oven is hot (at least 450, ovens vary a lot, even if the dial says 450) and that your pot has had enough time to really heat up.  

5. Doughy/undercooked in the middle? I'm not totally sure why this happens, but I think it because the crust starts to set before the boule has had time to finish springing up. Also could be because the dough is too dry/tight, so it can't expand. Hit Command-Z a few times, or toss that loaf and try again.

Are you an expert dough-slinger, or a beginning glutenphile? Let me know how your bread turns out, or what I'm doing wrong!  Posting a bread picture in the comments is totally not dorky. 






Post Comments

Add Your Comment!

(2000 character limit)

Judy on Sep 09, 2020:

Too doughy in the middle. More flour needed for the initial mix.

David on Mar 08, 2020:

I love bread. I love many of the Man Made articles. I would suggest there is no reason for profanity in the title or Man Made articles. Use your words. Things are at a contentious, aggressive, hateful, and profane level already. There is no need to needlessly add to it. In tragedies or emergencies profanity may occur and even drive home a point... but in most everything else profanity is gratuitous and unnecessary.

Johnny Risch on Mar 31, 2019:

Been making this since last year's post. I have a couple of recommendations. One, use fleischmann's yeast recipe for thick starter. Two, use a couple ounces more of flour and couple less ounces of water.

Donica Robinson on Aug 04, 2018:

I got so sick and tired of following Internet sourdough rules. The stuffs been around thousands of years. They did't have proofing boxes or gram measurements or scrapers or distilled water. I knead it until it feels like it should after a couple of rises, throw it in the pan I'll bake it in and let it rise once more. Score and bake. It may not look like every picture I see on the net, but if it's 190F in the center and it tastes awesome...I'm all over that.

Silver on May 09, 2018:

Turns out great every time. I have a licensed bakery out of my home and have been doing this for over 30 years (damn! I’m old!) I add more flour by gosh and golly. It is so easy. I grew up in Alaska on sourdough. This hits the spot! For those having trouble with moisture, make it a bit thicker. It thins out considerably with time as the wee yeasty beasties eat the flour and create lovely acids that make it sour yummylicious. Please, please, please at no point use a dough hook with this.

bruno on Jan 28, 2018:

@BR ahh! Sorry, I guess I misunderstood. Glad we worked it out.

BR on Jan 26, 2018:

@bruno I was asking because ounces are both a weight measure *and* a volume measure in the imperial system. :) Thanks for confirming that you are using ounces by weight, and not by volume, though. I’ll be trying this soon!

bruno on Jan 26, 2018:

Hi BR - ounces are a weight measure (imperial system), while grams are a weight measure in the metric system.

Hope you have a chance to make and enjoy this bread!

BR on Jan 26, 2018:

I want to make this! Are the ounces weight measures or volume measures? I assume they're volume, but as someone who (very) recently got into sourdough baking, I've gotten used to seeing ingredients in grams.

Katybeth Jensen on Jun 05, 2016:

Thanks. It took a whole lot more flour and kneeding with my dough hook. My Dutch Oven burn to a crisp...but the bread didn't turn out awful. The starter was fine---it had more to do with the rest of the ingridents. Oh well. I think I'll stick with what I know but thanks for the adventeur. Full disclouser I had often had issues with internet receipes so maybe it is me. 

bruno on Jun 05, 2016:

@katybeth sorry it didn't go so well for you! Maybe I just got really lucky with my starter, but I didn't do anything really fancy to get it to work. As I admitted, I'm not an expert, and the point of my post was only partly to tell people how to make bread (there's a vast amount of information on that online). The other part was (hopefully) to inspire some folks to try, seeing as how I've been able to do it, and I'm nothing special when it comes to baking.

Let me know how your second try goes!

Katybeth Jensen on Jun 05, 2016:

I am a bread maker (by recipe—not talent) and when my son asked me to make this I agreed. Although my faith in internet recipes took a huge dip after making ice cream bread, you made this bread look easy to make and tasty.   I babied my sourdough starter for over a week: Has it been fed, is it warm enough, did I discard correctly---more work than a dam hamster. I thought I followed all your directions word for word. I didn't have a "plastic bin" but assume tupperware would be good work for the sitting out/fridge part. However when I loving opened the tupperware all I had was a soupy mess. Taking some water out wasn’t going to work…BUT I’m not a quitter so I added more flour and now I am waiting to see if I can get a rise out it (does sourdough rise---I need to google) and then I am going loving turn it into a boule--and if I can’t do it lovingly ---bread hook will be engaged. I own a dutch oven and will bake accordingly—however my faith at this point is wavering and realize 

I should have looked more closely at 1 in the troubleshooting part of your post—I kind of thought you were an expert at this kind of bread and teaching people to make it. Bread is tricky—it’s good to write about what you know about…sigh. Oh well, there may still be hope. 

bruno on May 18, 2016:

@jacob - thanks, glad you enjoyed it!

Jacob W on May 17, 2016:

A) this looks delicious, and B) the savages comment made me laugh. I could totally see the sword being necessary in my house to allow the proper rest time.